Listen to this story — podcast version (Alex + Jordan, 5:01)
Also on the Personal Podcasts feed.
I am someone who sometimes feels he can make the world a better place and other times feels like it’s a lost cause.
With Leah, I wanted to make the world better. I wanted to get to understand her, so I could help her. I know it’s not my place to solve everyone’s life. There was something about her that made me want to try.
One night, I walked into the bar and I saw her standing by the piano with a drink in her hand. I ordered my Jack Daniels, built up my courage and walked up to her.
“Hello.” I said.
“Hello, you are back?”
“Yeah, you remember me?”
“You made me smile for a short while after I was rude to you.”
“You weren’t rude, you were honest.”
“Well these days it seems being honest can be considered rude.”
“Only to the insecure. My name is David, by the way.”
She stared at me and then put out her hand, “My name is Leah.”
She was not catatonic tonight, she was present and engaging. I ordered both of us drinks and I asked her to play a song.
“Whichever you choose.”
“Ok.”
The bar had the usual groups of people and a sprinkling of lone drinkers sitting around the bar. Behind the bar were several bartenders along with the bartender I had spoken with the past couple of times I had been there.
Leah began to play one note at a time. Slowly adding chords and segueing into a tune I could not recognize. She had a special talent and it should be shared.
The people around the bar began to pay attention and then went back to their conversations.
I began to feel a sense of…was it excitement? Inspiration? I couldn’t identify it but it felt like a spontaneous combustion of thousands of emotions.
She finished the tune to a smattering of applause. She stood up and sat across from me at the table I had been watching her from.
“I heard about you from Bill.”
“What did he say?” She asked.
“How you had a successful show and you just walked away from it.”
“It became too stressful. I began to spiral and…” she looked down, covered her eyes and stayed silent.
I stayed silent, giving her space. We sat there in silence.
“You know, I had a bad depression and it caused me to have, what seemed like constant panic and anxiety. I started therapy and added a pill. Within weeks I felt the anxiety easing.”
“I am not taking a pill.” She said defiantly.
“I am not telling you to, I’m just telling you my story. It’s my story not yours.”
“It’s just everyone is always telling me to take a pill, as if there is a magic pill that will take away all my problems.”
“Well, for me, I didn’t expect it to be magic. I didn’t know what to expect. It doesn’t fix your problems. It just helps you see them in a clearer way.”
She stood up and went to the piano. She began to play, “Melancholy Mood.” Which I knew from the Bob Dylan album, “Fallen Angels,” but it was actually written in the late 1930s. It’s funny how some music can be played in any time period and still leave an impression.
She finished playing and she sat there in a trance. At first I thought it was catatonia but she looked at me and smiled.
“You are different from the rest.”
“I’ll take that as a compliment. Why do you say that?”
“There is something about you that calms me. I don’t know what it is. I thought about you after we first met and I smiled each time. Strange for me, growing up with my father who was always frustrated and depressed and my mother who didn’t do anything to help him.”
“What was your mother like?”
“She was a strong woman. She barely smiled and hardly laughed but she was always there when we needed her. She was emotionally vacant but her presence made up for it.”
“My mother left before the war began. Her father sensed that Germany was no place for Jewish people. After the war, she found out that she lost all of her friends, and extended family. She never spoke about it and would wake up in the middle of the night screaming.”
“That must have been tough for you and your siblings.”
“It was. We were too young to understand.”
“I can’t even imagine what it’s like to lose everything and mostly everyone in your life. Your father, you told me he had given up his pianist career when he met your mother. Was he bitter?”
“He didn’t ever express that. I saw it, but he never complained. He had lost his whole family in the shoah, and was left with only memories. Still what they all lost in those days we can never comprehend. But in some way, I feel I inherited their struggle, they call that transgenerational trauma.”
“What does that mean?”
“It means that the children of survivors have the trauma and depression passed down to them.”
“Have you gone to therapy?” I asked.
“I don’t need therapy.”
“Do you think it’s a sign of weakness going to therapy?”
“Well, I have been thinking about it. I do see people around who move forward with their lives.”
“People who suffer from transgenerational trauma.”
She stayed silent. I kept silent, giving her the space she needed.
I thought about the pain that survivors had experienced and knew and was grateful that I could never understand any of the emotions they lived with.
She looked at me, “There’s something about you that tells me to move forward.”

Leave a Reply